As the owners of Hortons Flower Farm in Mattituck, we love exploring neighboring towns like Southold. With fresh-caught seafood, farm-to-table dining, and cozy cafés, this North Fork destination is a foodie’s paradise. Below, discover our favorite Southold restaurants and what makes each one a must-try.
Must-Try Restaurants in Southold
- North Fork Table & Inn
- A classic fine-dining gem focusing on locally sourced, seasonal dishes.
- Insider Tip: Reservations go fast—book well ahead if you’re planning a weekend visit.
- Southold Fish Market
- Grab the freshest catch, including lobster rolls and fish tacos. You can also buy raw seafood to cook at home.
- Best For: Seafood aficionados craving an authentic taste of the North Fork.
- Little Creek Oysters (Greenport)
- Just a short drive away, this quaint oyster shack lets you shuck your own oysters right on the waterfront.
- Pro Tip: Pair your oysters with a local wine for the ultimate East End pairing.
- Erik’s Breakfast & Lunch
- Hearty breakfasts and inventive lunch specials, ranging from crab cake sandwiches to avocado toast.
- Perfect For: Fueling up before a day of exploring vineyards and farms.
- The Halyard (Sound View Greenport)
- Upscale seafood dining with jaw-dropping sunset views over the Sound.
- Must-Try: Local oysters and their ever-popular clam chowder.
Quick Eats & Casual Bites
- Wednesday’s Table
Internationally inspired sandwiches and salads in a relaxed café setting. - The Market
Health-centric café offering organic smoothies, fresh juices, and wholesome eats. - Founders Tavern
A down-to-earth pub with craft beers, hearty burgers, and wings.
Farm-to-Table Dining & Local Ingredients
Many Southold-area restaurants spotlight local produce and freshly caught seafood:
- First and South (Greenport)
A creative American bistro emphasizing local flavors and seasonal specials. - The Frisky Oyster (Greenport)
Known for innovative seafood dishes served in a chic atmosphere. - Allure Chowder House & Oysteria (Southold)
Tantalizing chowders, waterfront views, and ocean-inspired creativity.
Pair Your Meal with Local Wine
No foodie trip to Southold is complete without sampling local vino:
- Croteaux Vineyards
Specializing in rosés that perfectly complement a seafood spread. - Sparkling Pointe
Renowned for top-tier sparkling wines—ideal for celebratory toasts. - Lenz Winery
Classic reds and whites that capture the essence of North Fork terroir.
Final Thoughts
From gourmet dining to casual seaside joints, Southold’s culinary scene offers something for every palate. After indulging in the local fare, swing by Hortons Flower Farm in Mattituck for fresh-cut blooms—or simply to chat about more hidden gems around the North Fork. Bon appétit!
