At Hortons Flower Farm in Mattituck, we’re constantly tasting our way through the North Fork—and Southold is a true standout. Whether you’re in the mood for elegant dining or a casual seafood fix, this charming town serves up a variety of delicious options. Here’s a closer look at our top picks.
Must-Try Restaurants in Southold
- North Fork Table & Inn
- A refined culinary experience known for farm-fresh ingredients and a stellar wine selection.
- Insider Tip: Reserve early—this spot is popular with foodies and visitors alike.
- Southold Fish Market
- Locals swear by their lobster rolls, fish tacos, and the freshest catch around.
- Perfect For: A casual, no-fuss seafood feast with genuine North Fork flavor.
- Little Creek Oysters (Greenport)
- Just minutes from Southold, shuck-your-own oysters and waterfront ambiance come together for a memorable meal.
- Pro Tip: Pair with a glass of local white wine for the ultimate briny delight.
- Erik’s Breakfast & Lunch
- Come hungry for generous breakfast plates and unique lunch options—think crab cake sandwiches and more.
- Best For: A relaxed meal before hitting the local vineyards.
- The Halyard
- Offering upscale waterfront dining, plus gorgeous sunset vistas over the Sound.
- Must-Try: Their popular New England-style clam chowder.
Casual Bites & Quick Eats
- Wednesday’s Table
A go-to for globally inspired salads, wraps, and sandwiches. - The Market
Health-forward café with organic juices, smoothies, and fresh bowls. - Founders Tavern
A local pub with craft beers, burgers, and a friendly neighborhood vibe.
Farm-to-Table Dining & Local Ingredients
Southold’s best restaurants honor the region’s farmland and coastal bounty:
- First and South (Greenport)
Showcasing local farms and fishermen in every dish. - The Frisky Oyster (Greenport)
Contemporary twists on seafood staples—prepare to be impressed. - Allure Chowder House & Oysteria (Southold)
Hearty chowders with a creative edge, plus scenic waterfront seating.
Pair Your Meal with Local Wine
A true North Fork dining experience isn’t complete without a splash of local vino:
- Croteaux Vineyards
Rosé specialties, perfect for pairing with light seafood or salads. - Sparkling Pointe
Raise a glass of bubbly to celebrate life on the East End. - Lenz Winery
Renowned for both reds and whites that mirror the terroir.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re seeking a refined dinner or a laid-back oyster shack, Southold’s dining scene is sure to delight. Stop by Hortons Flower Farm in Mattituck afterward for a bouquet of fresh flowers—or to chat all things North Fork food. Happy feasting!
